Featured image for Pros and cons of ground source heat pumps

Pros and cons of ground source heat pumps

In the quest for sustainable and energy-efficient heating solutions, ground source heat pumps (GSHPs) have long been considered a viable contender. These systems utilise the earth's relatively stable temperature to provide heating and cooling for various applications. However, like any technology, GSHPs come with their own set of advantages and limitations, and understanding when and where to deploy them becomes key.

In this blog post, we delve into the pros and cons of using ground source heat pumps in comparison to other technologies, shedding light on the optimal conditions for their implementation.

Pros of ground source heat pumps

  • Efficiency and consistency: One of the key advantages of GSHPs is their efficiency. The Earth's subsurface temperatures remain relatively constant throughout the year, allowing GSHPs to deliver consistent and efficient heating and cooling performance, regardless of the external weather conditions.
  • Catering to building demands: They can provide both heating and cooling at the same time, with heat recovery between the two, which can greatly increase efficiencies for buildings that have simultaneous heating and cooling demands.
  • Longevity: With just pipework loops installed below ground and all moving parts within the plantroom, these systems have a long operational lifespan, often exceeding 20 to 25 years for the heat pumps and up to 100 years for the ground loop. Their durable nature contributes to their appeal as a sustainable solution.
  • No external plant space: Apart from energy considerations another primary advantage is that no external plant space is required. This avoids taking away valuable external amenity space or adding bulky plant enclosures at roof level.
  • Acoustic considerations: In scenarios where noise pollution is a concern, GSHPs stand out. Unlike air-source heat pumps, which generate more noise due to their outdoor unit, GSHPs operate silently, making them ideal for residential areas and environments with stringent acoustic requirements.

Cons of ground source heat pumps

  • Installation costs: The initial installation costs of GSHPs can be significantly higher than other heating and cooling systems. This is attributed to the need for drilling deep boreholes or installing extensive ground loops, which involve significant labour and equipment costs.
  • Suitability of ground conditions: GSHPs heavily rely on the geological and hydrogeological properties of the site. Unsuitable ground conditions, such as rocky or densely packed soil, can hamper the effectiveness of the system.
  • Balancing heat extraction: While ground temperatures are often considered to be stable compared to ambient air temperatures, they do change over time if more heat is extracted from the ground than can be replaced. For well insulated residential schemes that have no cooling requirements the predominant load will be domestic hot water which is a year-round demand, and it may be that the average external air temperature over the whole year will be higher than the ground temperature after several years of heat extraction. This means that air source heat pumps could be a better option. Each site should therefore be reviewed with due consideration to annual load profiles in conjunction with ground conditions before ground source heat pumps are selected.
  • Specialised care: Specialist maintenance is recommended, not because the maintenance requirements are onerous or the equipment is complicated, but because it is important to monitor the ground loop temperatures and keep the correct levels of anti freeze in the ground loop.

When to choose ground source heat pumps

  • Projects with a good balance of heating and cooling loads are well suited to ground source due to the excellent efficiencies that can be achieved.
  • Sites with large accessible external spaces such as gardens or car parks where a piling rig can be manoeuvred relatively easily.
  • Sites where noisy external plant needs to be avoided either due to planning restrictions or a desire to prioritise external spaces for amenity use rather than plant.

The right choice for the right project

Ground source heat pumps offer a sustainable and efficient alternative for heating and cooling needs, particularly in scenarios where low noise levels and consistent performance are critical. While they come with initial investment considerations and geological constraints, their long-term benefits often outweigh these challenges. However, the decision to implement GSHPs should be based on careful evaluation of the project's requirements, financial considerations, and site-specific conditions. As environmental engineers, our goal is to find the most appropriate solution that aligns with the project's needs and contributes to a greener future.

If you would like to know more, please get in touch: hello@integrationuk.com